Who is the better NFL Draft prospect, PJ Williams or Carter Smith?

Compare their college production, consensus rankings, community draft activity, and scouting reports. These signals provide context for your own evaluation.

What stats are used to compare PJ Williams and Carter Smith?

Body measurements, position-relevant college production, and Fanspeak draft signals: consensus rank, ADP, mock-draft volume, and hype, plus a scouting note and most-drafted-by-franchise for each side.

Can I compare any two college prospects?

Yes. Use the comparison tool to pick any two 2027 draft-eligible players; every pairing has its own shareable page.

PJ Williams vs Carter Smith — NFL Draft Comparison

College Football

Player Comparison Tool

Compare any two college prospects head-to-head. Pick two players, or jump into a featured matchup.

College Football

NCAA FBS Hub

DEV · Light Dots

Dev preview · excluded from experiment tracking

PJ Williams vs Carter Smith — NFL Draft Comparison · Fanspeak

PJ Williams

SMU Mustangs

OT · #59

Carter Smith

Indiana Hoosiers

OT · #65

2025 college season

2025 college season: PJ Williams versus Carter Smith
PJ Williams	Statistic	Carter Smith
—	Tackles	1
—	Sacks	0.0
—	Tackles for Loss	0.0

Measurements

Measurements: PJ Williams versus Carter Smith
PJ Williams	Statistic	Carter Smith
6-5	Height	6-5
306 lb	Weight	310 lb

2027 draft projection

2027 draft projection: PJ Williams versus Carter Smith
PJ Williams	Statistic	Carter Smith
#74	Fanspeak rank	#20 (leading value)
OT 9	Position rank	OT 3 (leading value)
92.7	Average pick	33.6 (leading value)
Leading value: 1,831	Times drafted	1,765
Leading value: 72	Hype Score	72
175x	Most drafted to	230x

Latest shared season where available.
✓ Leading recorded value · — Unavailable

fanspeak.comScout. Compare. Draft.

Scouting reports Read both evaluations

PJ Williams

Dean Kindig

ICDraft: "- Good latch placement and elbow load on initial engagement, Keeps legs active post-contact, Aligns base to maximize leg drive and hip engagement, Torques through and finishes with rotational force"

Full player profile

Carter Smith

Dean Kindig

Best pass blocking grade after not allowing any Iowa pressures in scouted win. Trusting the Process started playing tackle in third grade, and joined a travel squad in middle school. Some balance and lean issues Kromer can fix. Favorite song is from Footloose: Holding Out For a Hero by Bonnie Tyler. Sparks: "one of the most reliable trench players in the class, even with some length questions that will need answering.".

Full player profile